SPECIALIZED EXPERTS IN TAX CONTROVERSY

Bjørnholm Law is a highly specialized boutique law firm. We assist in disputes with the Danish tax authorities, both prior to litigation and then throughout the appeals process, including where necessary employing mutual agreement procedures. Further, we offer advice on international taxation.

”Bjørnholm comes highly recommended by clients and is described as one of the best lawyers in Denmark to present clients before the courts in all tax-related controversy issues. One client said: ”Bjørnholm is a small boutique law firm which better than the top law firms is able to dedicate his full attention to his clients at hand. We see this as an advantage which together with our existing cooperation would recommend this firm.” (International Tax Review, ITR World Tax, fall 2016).

AREA OF EXPERTISE

We assist both businesses and individuals in controversies with the Danish tax authorities. We provide advice from when  the case is initiated by the Danish tax authorities until it is concluded, whether by agreement with the tax authorities or after an appeal process to the Danish courts and/or the European Court of Justice. We also assist with obtaining binding advanced rulings and applications to utilise Mutual Agreement Procedures. Away from controversies, we also give strategic tax advice in particular with respect to cross-border tax issues.

That a case is winnable does not automatically entail that it is won. Bjørnholm Law is a leading firm when it comes to winning cases. This is because we are thorough, we form a clear strategy for the case, and our business is focused on tax controversies. We build excellent working relations with other advisors involved in our cases. All these factors ensure that the arguments presented are to the point and well considered.

We are currently involved in several transfer pricing disputes at all levels of the process and concerns issues such as business restructurings (closing businesses and transforming from fully fledged to limited risk); financing; consecutive losses; and pricing of commodities and employee secondments. We are handling cases at the tax authority audit stage, including cases where Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is attempted, cases at the administrative appeal stage, court cases and cases under Mutual Agreement Procedure. Aside from transfer pricing the issues at stake in our current caseload include beneficial ownership; hydrocarbon taxation; employee share incentives and excise duties in international air traffic.

A survey conducted in 2014 showed that Nikolaj Bjørnholm was the second most successful tax lawyer at the Danish Supreme Court.

Bjørnholm Law has recently prevailed in the following cases:

2018:

• The Tax Tribunal: Transfer pricing case concerning the cessation of production activities in Denmark. The first case regarding business restructurings under chapter IX of the OECD TPG.

2017:

• The Tax Authorities: Transfer pricing case concerning amongst other interest rates resolved by ADR.

2016:

• The High Court: The first ever case on denial of access to the EU Arbitration Convention.

• The National Tax Tribunal: Taxation of the provision of free housing by a company to its majority shareholder.

• The Tax Authorities: Transfer pricing case concerning an amount in the hundreds of millions DKK with respect to a company which was loss making for almost two decades.

2015:

• The Supreme Court: Hydrocarbon taxation of financial income. The first hydrocarbon tax case ever heard by the courts. We also acted for the taxpayer before the High Court in 2013.

• The National Tax Tribunal: Transfer pricing case on hired out employees.

• The National Tax Tribunal: Taxation of an individual receiving funds from the UK.

2014:

• The High Court: Damages due to alleged misinformation on part of the seller in a M&A transaction.

2013:

• The High Court: Hydrocarbon taxation of financial income. The first hydrocarbon tax case ever heard before the courts.

• The High Court: Taxation of funds received in a failed attempt to complete a capital increase of hundreds of millions DKK.

2012:

• The Tax Tribunal: Transfer pricing case on interest rate.

• The Tax Authorities: Transfer pricing case concerning an amount in the millions of DKK with respect to a company which was loss making for almost a decade.

2011:

• The Supreme Court: Deduction of management fees for a venture fund.

• The High Court: Right to resumption of car registration duties based on new precedents from the Supreme Court.

• The Tax Tribunal: Refund of taxes paid on tax exempt per diems.

• The Tax Authorities: Withholding tax on interest and dividend of hundreds of millions DKK due to lack of beneficial ownership.


RATINGS

Our expertise within taxation is acknowledged by leading independent rating organisations.

Chambers Europe

2019: Rated as individual in tier 1

2018: Rated as individual in tier 1

2017: Rated as individual in tier 1

Nikolaj Bjørnholm, founder of Bjørnholm Law, is a seasoned tax practitioner with a strong track record in transfer pricing cases and employee incentive schemes, often advising clients from the technology and energy fields. Clients say: "He has a very high level of technical knowledge and provides valuable input.” (2019)

“Nikolaj Bjørnholm of Bjørnholm Law is an experienced tax professional who is principally renowned for his work on tax litigation and highlighted as "one of the strongest litigators in Denmark," frequently handling cases relating to transfers pricing. Sources describe him as "very pleasant, always calm, kind and open to listening to whatever you have to say," while another adds: "He had courage in his convictions and is able to be quite bullish in saying whether you should fight or settle in a case.” (2018)

“Nikolaj Bjørnholm of Bjørnholm Law is noted for his extensive experience in tax law and continues to advise as a sole practitioner after leaving Plesner in 2016. He focuses on contentious tax issues, litigation and corporate tax. Sources describe him as ”very talented” and both ”technically and commercially good.” (2017)

The Legal 500

2019: Ranked in tier 3

Bjørnholm Law 'has demonstrated extremely strong credentials in managing and winning disputes, especially in the field of transfer pricing'. Group co-head Nikolaj Bjørnholm is 'always on top of the situation when managing complex cases' and has 'a determined approach to finding appropriate solutions to the benefit of the client', and fellow practice head Bodil Tolstrup is 'extremely thorough in the preparation of any case matter' and 'very experienced when litigating the case in court'.

ITR World Tax

2020: Tier 2 in Tax Controversy

2020: Tier 4 in General Corporate Tax

2019: Tier 2 in Tax Controversy

2019: Tier 3 in General Corporate Tax

2018: Tier 3

2017: Firm to watch

“Bjørnholm and Tolstrup both specialise in controversies in tax and tranfer pricng and the boutique is already recognised in both world tax and world transfer pricing rankings”. (ITR, 2019)

“The practice has been able to secure prominent clients on account of its outstanding record in litigation before the Danish courts. These cases include negotiations and settlements at the tax tribunal. One client said: ”Bjørnholm Law has the right balance between tax expertise, experience and pragmatism, with quite a good understanding of the business”. (ITR, 2018)

“He is a recognised litigator and is highly spoken of by his peers. In 2016, he prevailed before the High Court in the first case of denial of access to the EU arbitration convention. He is working on various tax controversies in relation to transfer pricing, beneficial ownership and hydrocarbon taxation, among other things. Bjørnholm comes highly recommended by clients and is described as one of the best lawyers in Denmark to present clients before the courts in all tax-related controversy issues".

One client said: ”Bjørnholm is a small boutique law firm which better than the top law firms is able to dedicate his full attention to his clients at hand. We see this as an advantage which together with our existing cooperation would recommend this firm”. (ITR, 2017)

ITR World Transfer Pricing:

2020: Tier 3

2019: Tier 3

2018: Tier 3

2017: Firm to watch

"Held in high regard by clients and firms alike, Bjørnholm has been rated as one of the best tax lawyers in Denmark. The firm has been able to secure prominent clients on account of his outstanding record as a litigator, representing clients before the Danish courts in a number of audits. This includes negotiations, settlements and oral procedures at the tax tribunal”. (ITR, 2018)

“He is a recognised litigator and was highly spoken of by his peers and clients. One client said: “We have used Bjørnholm Law on several occasions and have benefitted from their professionality and commitment”. (ITR, 2017)

ITR – Tax Controversy Leaders Guide

Nikolaj Bjørnholm is listed in 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014 and 2013

ITR – Women in Tax Leaders Guide

Bodil Tolstrup is listed in 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016 and 2015

ITR – TP Leaders Guide

Nikolaj Bjørnholm is listed in the 2019 guide

Who’s Who Legal Corporate Tax: Controversy and Advisory

2019: Thought Leades Global Elite 2019 - Corporate Tax: Nikolaj Bjørnholm is listed as Global Elite Thought Leader

2019: Thought Leaders - Corporate Tax 2019: Nikolaj Bjørnholm is listed as Thought Leader

2018: Global Leader - Corporate Tax: Nikolaj Bjørnholm is listed as Recommended

2018: Nikolaj Bjørnholm is listed as leading individual and one of four EMEA, Global Elite Thought Leaders, Corporate Tax - Controversy 2018

"The "excellent" Nikolaj Bjørnholm at Bjørnholm Law is highlighted by sources as "among the highest-regarded and most successful lawyers at the Supreme Court" in Denmark. He emerges as the top name in the jurisdiction in our research this year."

Client Choice Award / International Law Office

2018: Winner of Corporate Tax

Best Lawyers

2016: Lawyer of the year within taxation (recognized since 2009)


NEWS

October 2019

ITR (International Tax Review) has recently published new editions of the guides; World Tax, World TP, Women in Tax, TP Leaders and Tax Controversy Leaders. Find more information here

Notably, Bjørnholm Law is ranked tier 2 in Tax Controversy and the only law firm with a highly regarded transfer pricing individual. Find more information here

August 2019

In the spring of 2019 Bjørnholm law prevailed in two cases.

In May 2019 the National Tax Tribunal found in favor of our client in a transfer pricing dispute concerning allocation of risk and thus accepted that group related counterparties could bear the risk of the other party’s failure to take delivery / deliver goods without this being separately priced. The decision has not been appealed to the courts. The decision is not published as the factual circumstances could not be sufficiently anonymized.

In March 2019 our client and the tax authorities reached a settlement whereby our client obtained a refund of excess surcharge (“restskattetillæg”) of a significant mDKK amount (equaling +90% of the original claim). The case had been pending at the National Tax Tribunal for more than two years when Bjørnholm Law was retained by the client in December 2018.

May 2019

Bjørnholm Law has contributed to the latest edition of ”Tax Management International Forum” concerning Tax Reporting Units. Read our contribution here Denmark March 2019

April 2019

Nikolaj Bjørnholm will speak at the 19th Annual U.S. and Europe Tax Practice Trends Conference to be held in Paris 3-5th April 2019. The conference is organised by American Bar Association. Find more information here

Once again Nikolaj Bjørnholm will be a panelist and the topic will be “Transfer Pricing Cases and Dispute Resolution Mechanisms”.

December 2018

Landmark transfer pricing case on business restructuring stands.

On 8 September 2018, the Danish Tax Tribunal decided in favor of a taxpayer in a TP case on business restructurings (OECD TPG, chapter IX). The ruling is now final as the Danish Ministry of taxation has decided not to appeal. The ruling from the Tax Tribunal can be found here

In the case the tax authorities claimed that significant accounting costs / losses incurred by a Danish subsidiary upon closure of a Danish production plant should be reimbursed by the multinational parent company as a taxable compensation. The Tax Tribunal ruled that the closure did not result in a transfer of something of value (neither tangible nor intangible assets were transferred) and likewise the closure did not result in changes to any existing contractual arrangements which would warrant reimbursement between third parties. Thus, the mere fact that a subsidiary suffered significant accounting costs / losses due to group decision to terminate Danish operations did not in itself warrant a TP correction.

Prior to the ruling from the Danish Tax Tribunal, the case also gave rise to a dispute on access to MAP under the EU Arbitration Convention (90/436), as the tax authorities alleged that the request for MAP did not met the minimum requirements set in the code of conduct. The tax payer also prevailed on this matter. My article on the decision by the High Court has been published by the IBFD in European Taxation, December 2016, page 534-540. The article contains a description of the facts and arguments. The ruling from the High Court can be found here

Bjornholm Law is proud to have represented the taxpayer in both cases.

October 2018

Once again Nikolaj Bjørnholm will speak at the Annual Conference of the International Bar Association to be held in Rome in October 2018.

The topic will be “New Trends in the Relationship Between Tax Administrations and Taxpayers”. In the panel will be tax officers from the UK and Italy, a professional from the banking sector and leading private practice tax lawyers.

September 2018

The Tax Tribunal has decided in favor of the taxpayer in a transfer pricing case concerning business restructurings under chapter IX of the OECD TPG. Bjornholm Law represented the taxpayer.

June 2018

Bjørnholm Law has contributed to the latest edition of Practising Law Institute’s Treatise that is produced in conjunction with PLI’s “Tax Strategies for Corporate Acquisitions, Dispositions, Spin-Offs, Joint Ventures, Financings, Reorganizations & Restructurings 2018”. Read our contribution Denmark June 2018

May 2018

In 2017 the Danish tax authorities introduced Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Four cases have since then been subject to ADR proceedings, and Bjørnholm Law has acted as advisor on three of these cases. Based on this experience Bjørnholm Law is still of the opinion that ADR is a relevant additional mechanism of solving disputes.

Bodil Tolstrup and Nikolaj Bjørnholm shared their experience and thoughts with Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) for the Association of Danish Tax Lawyers.

April 2018

Together with head of Danish Competent Authority and lead mediator Bo Darling Larsen, Bodil Tolstrup and Nikolaj Bjørnholm presented the concept Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) and their experience and thoughts during a training day organized by the tax directors of leading Danish corporations.

March 2018

Bjørnholm Law has contributed to the latest edition of ”Tax Management International Forum” concerning Acquisition Financing. Read our contribution Denmark – March 2018.

November 2017

ITR World Tax 2018 has been published and we are proud to be placed in Tier 3-Denmark given that we were established only a year ago. We will do our best to move higher next year.

August 2017

The Danish Tax Council has for the first time applied the general anti abuse rule (GAAR) which was enacted in 2015 and based on the equivalent GAARs introduced in EU tax law. We have written an article on this decision in the Danish journal on international taxation “Skat Udland” (SU 2017, 147).

June 2017

Bodil Tolstrup and Nikolaj Bjørnholm gave a lecture to the Danish Association for EU Tax Law regarding the new EU-directive on Mutual Agreement Procedure and Arbitration in tax cases. Se our slides here (only in Danish).

April 2017

Nikolaj Bjørnholm has participated as speaker/panelist on the Transfer Pricing Controversy Panel at the ABA 17th Annual Tax Planning Strategies U.S. and Europe Conference in Barcelona.

January 2017

Nikolaj Bjørnholm has participated in the 6th Annual IBA Tax Conference as co-chair of the panel discussing International Tax Dispute Resolution.


PEOPLE

Nikolaj Bjørnholm is an experienced litigator and is one of the few tax lawyers having appeared before the Supreme Court more than 15 times since 2000. He is ranked as a leading tax lawyer in Chambers; Legal 500; Who´s Who Legal; Which Lawyer; and Tax Directors Handbook among others, where clients describe him as “talented”; “intelligent, creative and responsive”; “fast and goes straight to the issue”; “exceptionally good”; and “particularly strong in international tax and litigation”. During his career he has continuously published articles in both Danish and international tax journals, and he has been correspondent to Tax Notes International; European Taxation and BNA.

Nikolaj Bjørnholm graduated from the University of Copenhagen in 1991 (LLM) and the Copenhagen Business School in 1996 (Diploma in Economics). Upon graduating in 1991 he spent five months with the EU Commission, after which he has continuously worked as a lawyer (partner) with some of the major Danish / Scandinavian law firms: Bech-Bruun (1992 – 2010); Hannes Snellman (2011 – 2013); and Plesner (2014 – 2016). In 2016 he founded Bjørnholm Law together with Bodil Tolstrup.

Nikolaj Bjørnholm is a member of the International Bar Association (officer of the Taxation Committee 2003–2004 and 2009-2010); the American Bar Association; the International Fiscal Association; The Danish Bar Association; and the Danish Tax Lawyer Association.

Bodil Tolstrup is specialized in tax controversy within all areas of tax. She has represented clients varying from individuals and small independent businesses to venture funds and labor-unions. Bodil has published several articles in both Danish and international tax journals, and she is correspondent to BNA/Bloomberg.

Bodil Tolstrup graduated from the University of Copenhagen in 2002 (LLM). Upon graduating she worked as a legal officer with the Danish Tax Tribunal (the administrative tax appeals agency in Denmark) (2003-2005). Since then she has continuously worked as a lawyer with some of the major Danish / Scandinavian law firms: Bech-Bruun (2005 – 2010); Hannes Snellman (2011 – 2013); and Plesner (2014 – 2016). In 2016 she founded Bjørnholm Law together with Nikolaj Bjørnholm.

Bodil Tolstrup is a member of the International Fiscal Association; The Danish Bar Association; and the Danish Tax Lawyer Association.


CONTACT

Nikolaj Bjørnholm

Advokat (H), HD(R)
Attorney-at-law, Partner

T. +45 30 93 71 93

nbj@bjornholmlaw.com

Bodil Tolstrup

Advokat (L)
Attorney-at-law, Partner

T. +45 20 12 06 90

bto@bjornholmlaw.com

Bjørnholm Law · Strandvejen 60 · 2900 Hellerup · Copenhagen · Denmark

Phone: +45 45 17 42 00 · VAT-no. 37937134